CookieYes vs Termly: which SMB consent tool wins in 2026?
CookieYes and Termly are two of the most popular consent tools for small and mid-sized businesses — both affordable, both with free tiers, both frequently shortlisted by the same buyers. But they come at the problem from opposite directions. CookieYes is banner-first: a consent platform built around cookie scanning and a solid banner, with a couple of policy generators attached. Termly is document-first: a suite of legal-policy generators that added a consent banner on top. Knowing which starting point matches your actual need is most of the decision.
This is a neutral, side-by-side comparison of CookieYes vs Termly for 2026 — positioning, pricing, scanning, auto-blocking, Google Consent Mode, GPC, document generators, strengths, weaknesses and who each is for. We'll also be honest about one thing neither is built around — US CIPA risk — and a third option worth knowing if that's your real concern. It's a product comparison, not legal advice.
The short version
- Choose CookieYes if you want a WordPress-native, banner-and-scanning-first tool with strong support and deeper cookie scanning — and you only need cookie/privacy policies.
- Choose Termly if you need a broad set of legal documents (terms, EULA, impressum, ecommerce policies) with consent bundled in, often at a lower single-site price, with phone support.
- Consider a third option if your real risk is US CIPA litigation rather than EU compliance or legal docs — both of these are GDPR-first, and neither is built for the wiretapping fact pattern. More below.
CookieYes vs Termly at a glance
The fastest way to frame it: pick by what you need more of — a strong banner and scanning (CookieYes), or a broad set of legal documents (Termly).
| CookieYes | Termly | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin / maker | CookieYes Ltd (UK), from 2018 (ex "Cookie Law Info") | Termly (US, Seattle); group.one / one.com family |
| Core positioning | Banner- & scanning-first (WordPress-native roots) | Document-first (legal generators + consent layer) |
| Policy generators | 2 (privacy, cookie) | ~10 (incl. T&Cs, EULA, impressum, ecommerce) |
| Pricing basis | Per domain, by pageviews | Per website; custom Agency quote at ~10+ |
| Free plan | Yes (~5,000 pageviews) | Yes (~10,000 banner views, 1 policy) |
| Scanning depth | Deeper (large DB, behind-login on top tier) | Lighter (fewer categories) |
| DSAR form | Not emphasized | ✓ All tiers |
| Support | Well-rated (chat/ticket) | Phone support (weekday hours) |
Whichever you're leaning toward, start by seeing what your site actually does. ConsentPixel's free scanner loads your site as a first-time visitor and shows every tracker that fires before consent — a useful baseline before you pick any tool.
Scan my site free →CookieYes: banner-first, scanning-strong
CookieYes (CookieYes Ltd, UK) launched in 2018 as the free "Cookie Law Info" WordPress plugin and grew into a self-serve consent platform built around cookie scanning and banner delivery. Its strengths are a large (100,000+) cookie database, deeper scanning (more pages per scan on higher tiers, behind-login scanning on its top tier), auto-blocking before consent on all tiers, Google Consent Mode v2 everywhere, consent logging even on free, and consistently well-rated support. It's a Google CMP partner. It includes two policy generators (privacy and cookie).
The trade-offs: it's priced per domain by pageviews, with overage charges that can surprise a high-traffic site; IAB TCF and GPC sit behind the Pro tier; some reviewers report occasional inaccurate cookie detection that required manual audits; and it has only the two document generators. If you need a broad set of legal documents, that's a gap CookieYes doesn't fill.
CookieYes is strongest for…
- WordPress sites that want a native plugin and responsive support.
- Teams that prioritise deep cookie scanning and a solid banner.
- Sites that only need cookie and privacy policies (and source other legal docs elsewhere).
- Single-site owners who want GPC and are fine on the Pro tier.
Termly: document-first, consent included
Termly (US-based, Seattle, part of the group.one/one.com family) started as a legal-policy-generator suite and added a consent banner on top. Its signature strength is breadth of documents: around ten attorney-crafted, auto-updated generators — privacy policy, cookie policy, terms and conditions, EULA, acceptable use, shipping, return/refund, disclaimer, impressum and accessibility — plus an embeddable DSAR form on all tiers, including free. It auto-blocks before consent on all tiers, supports Google Consent Mode v2 (advanced on Pro+), and offers phone support on weekdays. It's priced per website, and for a single site needing IAB TCF, its Pro+ tier is reported to undercut CookieYes Pro by roughly $10/month.
The trade-offs: its scanning is lighter (fewer categories, no published pages-per-scan limit), consent logging is Pro+ only, GPC isn't clearly listed (verify if you need it), multi-language is Pro+ only, and some reviewers find it pricey for the features or report the banner occasionally re-showing after consent. If your priority is the banner and scanning rather than documents, Termly is the lighter option there.
Termly is strongest for…
- Sites that need terms, a EULA, an impressum or ecommerce policies alongside consent.
- Non-WordPress sites and non-technical users who want guided document creation.
- Single-site buyers who want IAB TCF at a lower price.
- Teams that value phone support and a built-in DSAR form.
Feature-by-feature
Directional as of November 2026 — confirm current details on each vendor's site.
| Capability | CookieYes | Termly |
|---|---|---|
| Core focus | Banner + scanning | Legal documents |
| Policy generators | 2 (privacy, cookie) | ✓ ~10 |
| Cookie scanning depth | ✓ Deeper (large DB) | Lighter |
| Auto-block before consent | ✓ All tiers | ✓ All tiers |
| Google Consent Mode v2 | ✓ All tiers | Advanced on Pro+ |
| IAB TCF | Pro+ | Pro+ |
| GPC | Pro+ | Not clearly listed — verify |
| Consent logging | ✓ All tiers | Pro+ only |
| DSAR form | Not emphasized | ✓ All tiers |
| Multi-language | ✓ From Basic | Pro+ (13 languages) |
| Support | ✓ Well-rated chat/ticket | ✓ Phone (weekday) |
| Pricing basis | Per domain (pageviews) | Per website |
"Partial" reflects tier-gating or a lighter implementation, not absence. No tool "guarantees compliance."
Pricing compared
Both are SMB-priced with free tiers, but metered differently — CookieYes by pageviews per domain, Termly by website. Directional for 2026 (confirm with each vendor):
- CookieYes: free (~5,000 pageviews, 1 domain); paid tiers reported ~$10 (Basic), $25 (Pro), $55 (Ultimate) per domain/month, with pageview overage on lower tiers.
- Termly: free (~10,000 banner views, 1 policy); paid tiers reported ~$10–$20/month; multi-domain moves to a custom Agency quote at roughly 10+ sites.
The practical read: for a single site that needs legal documents plus consent, Termly is often the better value (more generators, reportedly cheaper for single-site IAB TCF). For banner-and-scanning depth, CookieYes is competitive. Both get expensive at scale — CookieYes through per-domain billing, Termly through the Agency-quote jump — so if you run many sites, model the total before committing.
The honest tie-breaker on price: don't compare the headline tiers — compare what each bundles. Termly's price includes ~10 legal documents you'd otherwise pay a generator or lawyer for; CookieYes's price buys deeper scanning and a stronger banner. You're not comparing two banners, you're comparing a banner-led tool and a documents-led tool that happen to overlap on consent.
Which should you choose?
| Choose CookieYes if… | Choose Termly if… |
|---|---|
| You're on WordPress and want a native, well-supported plugin | You need many legal documents (T&Cs, EULA, impressum, ecommerce) |
| Deep cookie scanning and a strong banner are your priority | You want guided, attorney-crafted document creation |
| You only need cookie + privacy policies | You want a single-site IAB TCF option at a lower price |
| You want GPC and consent logging on a single site | You value phone support and a built-in DSAR form |
A third option — if your real risk is US CIPA, not just GDPR
Here's the part a straight CookieYes-vs-Termly comparison leaves out: both are SMB, GDPR-first tools, and while both handle CCPA to a degree, neither is built around CIPA — the California Invasion of Privacy Act, whose wiretapping theory drives the current wave of US website-tracking demand letters. If your traffic is mostly US and your real exposure is litigation rather than EU compliance or legal paperwork, the CookieYes-vs-Termly question may be the wrong one.
CIPA claims turn on third-party trackers — especially session recorders like Hotjar, FullStory and Microsoft Clarity — firing before a visitor consents, and on whether you can prove consent came first. Auto-blocking and Google Consent Mode (which both tools offer) help, but Consent Mode signals consent to Google's tags rather than guaranteeing a third-party session recorder never loads. We cover the mechanics in one click, 415 requests and track the cases in the CIPA Lawsuit Tracker.
Full disclosure — the one bit about our own tool. ConsentPixel is a CIPA-first option worth shortlisting if US litigation is your concern: it hard-blocks session recorders before consent, honors GPC by default, and keeps a verifiable consent record built around the US fact pattern. It isn't trying to out-generate Termly on legal documents or replace CookieYes's WordPress-native simplicity for a pure-GDPR banner — it's the pick when the risk you're managing is American, not European. See the CookieYes alternatives and Termly alternatives guides for the fuller field. (Informational, not legal advice.)
Switching between CMPs without downtime
- Audit what fires today. Run a free scan to baseline every tracker and when it loads under your current tool.
- Install the new tool in parallel / staging. Don't remove the old banner first; compare behaviour side by side.
- Port your documents and categories. If you're moving off Termly, make sure you've exported or re-generated the legal documents you relied on; if moving to it, generate them before switching.
- Map Consent Mode v2 signals so ad/analytics tags read the new consent state — the usual breakage point.
- Verify before/after, switch live, remove the old tool, and archive the old consent records.
Key takeaways
CookieYes vs Termly, in brief
- CookieYes = banner + scanning. WordPress-native, deeper scanning, strong support, 2 policy generators. GPC/TCF are Pro+.
- Termly = documents. ~10 attorney-crafted generators + a DSAR form on all tiers, phone support, often cheaper single-site — but lighter scanning, consent logging Pro+, GPC unclear.
- Pick by what you need more of — a strong banner (CookieYes) or broad legal documents (Termly).
- Both are SMB, GDPR-first, and neither is built around US CIPA.
- If US litigation is your risk, add a CIPA-first option (blocking before consent + provable consent) to the shortlist.
The bottom line
Between these two, the decision is mostly about your starting need. If you want a strong banner with deep scanning and you'll source legal documents elsewhere, CookieYes is the better fit. If you need a broad set of legal documents with consent bundled in — and often at a lower single-site price — Termly wins. Both are solid SMB choices; both bill in ways that get expensive at scale, so run your own numbers.
The caveat worth repeating: both are GDPR-first tools, and if your real exposure is US CIPA litigation rather than EU compliance or legal paperwork, compare them against a CIPA-first option too — and, either way, scan your own site first so you're choosing on what actually fires before consent, not on a feature grid.
See what fires on your site before "accept" — whichever tool you pick. Run a free ConsentPixel scan to find every tracker loading before consent, including session recorders. It's a free baseline that makes any CMP decision better-informed.
Get your free privacy scan →